I defy those who say that the whole is broken and can never be reconstituted. I am what I eat, and I eat whole foods (while I am not fooled by "Whole Foods"), I am, on the whole, a whole being speaking to what is whole in you. I do not believe you cannot, on the whole, wholly see me and hear me as a whole according to your sense of a whole. If it were my sense of the whole, if I could fully be known or know you, you couldn't be whole and complete and see me as such. We would be one in the same and like everything else, unable to produce ourselves in the absence of an other.
I believe all the flap about fragments is a ruse, to avoid responsibility. A cowardly failure to take a leap of faith in what a computer can't tally and verify, so there's no risk whatsoever, on the surface of it. Not that we aren't bravest soldiers in the battle to win a place in the sun. We've got no energy left to risk a new shared idea that might not bear fruit for us for years, and might even set us back temporarily -- as a point on a wheel must regress to advance. We know though that nothing is riskier than trying to factor out all risk. Science herself loathes the fact that science, because it rests on literal proofs, has been made into a god. Science is a noble being, devout to whole being, always pointing to it, and horrified in being turned into an idol to replace it. Science is a finger pointing at the moon, not the moon itself.
We say -- we're free of empty superstition, free of religion, we live in chaos and fragments. Then we bow down and worship a mere tool, science. Nothing is greater than the tool. The artist is another idol, but the artist at best points to the art. The art object is another pointing finger, it points to you, in whom the whole to which it points dwells. As Bruce Lee says of a finger pointing at the moon: Don't watch the finger, or you will miss all that heavenly glory.
Yet we stare fixated at these pointing fingers, science, artists, art objects (what's the point of making non-objective art if you worship the art object?). Meanwhile, I happened to be among ten or so oddballs who showed up one night at the poetry reading of the one of the world's greatest poets. Alas, he too, worshipped by would be poets, would twist poetry into fragments to conform it to the orthodox creed of fragments, if that were possible, but fortunately, poetry is more powerful than poets, especially the world's greatest.
We worship pointing fingers (it helps that they're phallic of course), science, artists, art objects, but if there's nothing to point to, they can't be pointing fingers, yet they are pointing fingers, so there IS something they are pointing to, but we're not allowed to say we believe in it, because we're only allowed to believe in pointing fingers. We're only allowed to believe in language, not what it signifies, but if it signified nothing, it wouldn't be language. Think on it. Do not look there or there. You are the significant signified. The pointed to is within you. It cries -- do not worship idols, or your ship will crash on the rocks. Plus ca change...
Yet the academic world as it holds sway over art criticism as it holds sway over the gallery districts, if not the best gallerists at least, professes this neurotic, paralyzed credo of fragments more stridently than a Catholic holds to the Apostles Creed, for the Catholic professes only to believe the Apostles Creed, not to know it. Nor does the Catholic necessarily take it literally. Nor do most Catholics demand their creed be taught in public schools. Not so the creed of the fragment. Pledge allegiance to this creed, or you won't get your PhD in any discipline in the so called secular university.
Still, I say they might not yet know they know it, but if they could shut out the noise and wean themselves from the rhetoric, every artist and art lover would know that he or she knows that the whole made in seeking another whole seeking to make it whole IS whole, and the creed of the fragment is a lie, the lie of literalism. The artists of the last century only sought to be reticent about the pointed-to, not turn reticence into prohibition. the quiet faith, say of e.e. cummings, into a decreed credo requiring sticking one's finger into every wound to verify a man is bleeding. I don't let those early modernists off scott free though. They planted the seeds and poisoned the soil with hubristic perfectionism and idealism.